Why India can't give away Kashmir - Quora Question

Q: What is the reason of India for taking Kashmir?


A: Kashmir is the fountainhead of Indian civilisation approximately 5000 year old.

Kashmir's Saraswat river from whose banks all Bramhins of India are originated. All Gaur Saraswat Bramhins & many Bengali Bramhins originate from Kashmir. Rajtarangini is the historical literature that supports the above.

Name Kashmir not changed for last 5000 years. Nilmat Puranas is a product of Kashmir. Panini's the Great Sanskrit grammar was written in Kashmir. Compared to this the name Gujarat of PM Modi's state is only 57 year old.

India cannot give away its source of civilization. Every Kashmiri in Kashmir were Pundits & now converted to others with time. So there is genetic connection with the rest of India.

Kashmir wants freedom is a purported lie generated, fact is Kashmiris want India's culture, tradition, secularism, democracy, this demonstrated through demand for Panchayati Raj in Lalchowk, Srinagar in 2018. Kashmiris wishes to be part of India's success story & not be a part of any kind of theocratic failed state. Kashmir's Constitution written by Kasmiri themselves starts with line “ Kashmir is the integral part of India”

Most of the Maulavis & Maulanas in Kashmir valley are outsiders mainly from Bihar, Uttar Pradesh.

Instrument of accession signed by Maharaja Hari Singh of Kashmir in 1947 clearly acceeds to India duly countersigned by Lord Mountbatten, this is rare example of countersigned accession out of around 600 princely states that ceeded to either of the two dominions of India or Pakistan. That Maharaja of Kashmir had option to remain independent is a lie & there is no such provision in either Gov't of India Act 1935 & Indian Independence Act 1947. Princely state should accede to either of the two dominions is the provision. On top of it dominions had the right to capture any princely state through force. That's what happened to Hyderabad.

Hence nothing should be imposed on Kashmir except their own free will.

No external aid is necessary for furtherance of Kashmiri cause. Kashmir with developmental efforts by India in Kashmir will become one of the best state in India. Late Atal Bihari Vajpayee has declared way back in 2002 to implement Jammu Ladakh all weather Rail & Road link as national project. Rest of India vows to make Atalji's dream a success of Kashmir as one of Insaniyat, Jhumuriat & Kashmiriyat.

JaiHind

Is BJP / RSS represent Hindu extremism Quora Question

Calling RSS and / or BJP Hindu extremist group without sound admissible evidence attracts criminal defamation & may lead to life imprisonment.

Extremism & Terrorism are intensely violent terms & better be avoided being used in ordinary course of conversation. To understand the terms Terrorism / Extremism please read here

BJP is the World's largest political entity & RSS is the World's largest Social organisation. Let us not go too far back into the history of India, like Indo-China war of 1962 where RSS fought alongside Indian Army & in 1963 Nehru invited RSS in the Republic day function!

Let us therefore analyse the most current natural calamities in India the one of #KeralaFloods, wherein RSS volunteers taking risks of their own lives rendered selfless relief services.

Recently RSS were there in Nepal Earthquake, Chennai Floods, Kashmir Floods: which Terrorist or extremist organisation gets involved in relief & rehabilitation works? Anyone can show any credible evidence of Al Quida, Jaish e Mohammad, Laskar e Taiba, ISIS involved in any kind of relief & humanitarian work? Rohingya refugees are also not being extended any help by Pakistan etc.

Now RSS has built Swami Vivekananda memorial at Kanyakumari by collecting private funds by its celebrated Swyamsevak Late Eknathji Ranade. Which extremist organisation is found in building national monuments? On the contrary it is the Dharma(धर्म) of the extremist organisations to destroy historic monuments.

RSS believes in वसुधैवकुटुम्बकम् सर्वे भवन्तु सुखिनः सर्वे सन्तु निरामयाः। Please read former President of India's tweet as below of what he perceives about BJP, RSS Nationalism :-


Pranab Mukherjee
✔
@CitiznMukherjee
My Address to the Pracharaks on Nation,Nationalism & Patriotism. Indian #Nationalism emanated from "Universalism", the philosophy of वसुधैव कुटुम्बकम् & सर्वे भवन्तु सुखिनः
सर्वे सन्तु निरामयाः
Our national identity has emerged through confluence, assimilation & coexistence.

8:18 PM - Jun 7, 2018
13.7K
5,480 people are talking about this
Twitter Ads info and privacy


According to Supreme Court in 1995, on the Landmark Judgment on Hindutva, is that “Hindu is not a religion but a way of life & state of mind” & all Indians are Hindus, irrespective of their religion.

Dharma (धर्म) is not religion but a duty, responsibility, righteousness, rule of law towards the environment where you negotiate yourselves everyday.

Therefore, Indians will be passionate, patriotic & nationalistic about its own country भारतवर्ष or Bharat or India, that can't be equated with Hindu extremism.

Yes agreed, there is a national movement, there is uprising of national consciousness to one of peace, prosperity, unity integrity & huge resistance to invasion on our culture, traditions, territory.

If that is being branded as Hindu extremism by ISIS propagandists then, let it be,

JaiHind

BharatMataKiJai

VandeMataram

178 Views · · Answer requested by